Read Time: 11 min
Most winters in Central Pennsylvania, an early cold snap catches homeowners off guard. You turn on the bathroom faucet on a frosty morning and get a faint hiss or a slow trickle. That usually means a frozen pipe, hidden behind drywall, in a crawlspace, or at an outdoor spigot.
Water expands by about 9% as it freezes. Inside a copper or PEX line, that expansion drives pressure high enough to split the pipe, and a single rupture can release hundreds of gallons into a finished basement or ceiling before you notice.
The good news: you can prevent frozen pipes with a few hours of seasonal prep. This guide covers why pipes actually burst, how to winterize outdoor spigots, the weak spots common in Lancaster County homes, and what to do if a line freezes before you’re ready.
TL;DR / Quick Summary
Preventing frozen pipes comes down to three things: draining outdoor spigots, protecting lines in unheated spaces, and giving trapped water pressure somewhere to go.
Key Takeaways:
- Pipes burst from pressure trapped between an ice blockage and a closed faucet, not from the ice itself.
- Disconnect hoses and shut off interior spigot valves before the first hard freeze.
- Drafty stone foundations in older Lititz-area homes are a common freeze point.
- Insulate exposed lines with foam sleeves at least 3/4 inch thick, seams taped.
- If a faucet stops flowing, leave it open and thaw gently from the faucet back toward the blockage.
Why Pipes Burst: It’s the Pressure, Not the Ice
Most frozen pipes don’t split where the ice forms. They split downstream, in a section that never froze. Knowing why changes how you protect your plumbing.
When the air around a pipe stays below 32°F for several hours, ice builds inward from the pipe wall until it forms a solid plug. That plug traps water between itself and the nearest closed faucet. As more ice forms, it pushes against that trapped water, which can’t compress.
Normal household water pressure runs about 40 to 80 PSI. Behind an ice plug, it can climb into the thousands of PSI, enough to tear copper or pull a PEX fitting apart, often several feet from the freeze. Freeze research summarized by the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) points to this downstream pressure, not the ice itself, as the cause of the break.
That’s why a dripping faucet works. Moving water is slower to freeze, but the bigger benefit is pressure relief: an open faucet gives that pressure an exit, so the pipe is far less likely to split even if ice forms.
How to Winterize Outdoor Spigots

Outdoor spigots (also called hose bibbs or sillcocks) are the most exposed plumbing in your home. Winterize them as soon as you can, ideally before the first hard freeze, which in Lancaster County often arrives in late October or early November.
- Disconnect every hose, splitter, and timer. A connected hose holds water in the spigot’s valve body. Even a frost-free spigot can’t drain with a hose attached, and when that water freezes it can crack the valve inside your wall. Often you won’t know until spring, when you turn it on and water pours into the basement.
- Close the interior shutoff valve. In the basement or crawlspace, follow the line feeding each spigot back to its shutoff. Turn a round handle fully clockwise, or turn a lever handle so it sits perpendicular to the pipe.
- Open the outdoor faucet to drain it. Let the remaining water run out, then leave the faucet open all winter so any water that seeps past the shutoff can escape.
- Open the bleeder cap. Most spigot shutoffs have a small brass cap on the side facing the outside wall. Hold a cup under it, unscrew it to drain a few ounces, then thread it back on finger-tight. This clears the last water from the line between the valve and the wall.
Frost-free spigots usually don’t need steps 2 through 4, because their valve sits 6 to 12 inches inside the heated wall. Disconnecting the hose is still essential.
If your spigots are the older standard type with no interior shutoff, upgrading to a frost-free, anti-siphon model is the most reliable fix.
Freeze-Prone Spots in Lancaster County Homes
Central Pennsylvania homes share a few weak points that show up winter after winter. In our decades serving Lititz, Warwick Township, and Hershey, these are where our team often finds frozen lines.
Older Basements and Stone Foundations
Many older homes in Lititz and the surrounding townships sit on fieldstone or rubble-stone foundations. Over the years, small gaps open where the wood framing meets the top of the foundation wall. On windy nights, cold air pours through those gaps and across the pipes feeding kitchens and upstairs bathrooms. Sealing them with spray foam or foam board stops the draft before it can freeze a line.
Unheated Crawlspaces
Pipes in an uninsulated crawlspace are exposed to near-outdoor temperatures. Close foundation vent covers by mid-November, and wrap every line in closed-cell foam sleeves with at least a 3/4-inch wall thickness. Tape every seam and joint, since even small gaps leave bare pipes exposed.
Pipes in Exterior Walls
Sinks on outside walls, bathrooms over garages, and rooms with cantilevered overhangs often have supply lines outside the home’s heated envelope. When temperatures fall below 20°F, open the cabinet doors under those sinks so warm room air reaches the pipes. If a line runs through a poorly insulated exterior wall, let that faucet drip at a pencil-thin stream overnight.
What to Do If a Pipe Freezes
If a faucet gives you a trickle or nothing on a cold morning, assume the line is frozen. Acting carefully now can keep it from bursting as it thaws.
- Leave the faucet open. Open both hot and cold. As the ice melts, the water needs somewhere to go, and flowing water helps melt the rest of the blockage.
- Find the frozen section. Check the coldest spots first: crawlspaces, rim joists, unheated garages, and cabinets on exterior walls. Look for frost on the pipe or a slight bulge.
- Check for a split before you thaw. If you see a crack or a separated fitting, shut off your main water valve and call a plumber. Thawing a split pipe turns it into a leak.
- Apply gentle heat. Use a hairdryer, a space heater kept at least 3 feet from anything flammable, electric heat tape installed per its instructions, or towels soaked in hot water. Start at the faucet end and work toward the blockage so melting water can drain out.
- Keep going until full pressure returns at every fixture, then check the area for drips.
Never thaw a pipe with a torch or any open flame. The common mistakes section below explains why.
What You Can Handle vs. When to Call a Pro

Tasks Most Homeowners Can Do
- Disconnecting hoses and adding spigot covers: About 15 minutes per spigot, no tools needed.
- Fitting foam pipe insulation: Pre-slit sleeves, a utility knife, and tape are all it takes for pipes you can reach.
- Opening cabinets and dripping faucets: Free, safe habits for the coldest nights.
Tasks for Confident DIYers
- Installing heat cable: Self-regulating cable with a built-in thermostat, plugged into a GFCI-protected outlet.
- Sealing foundation drafts: Spray foam around the sill and any pipe or wire openings through the foundation.
When to Call a Professional
- A pipe has split or a fitting has separated: Shut off the main valve first, then call a licensed plumber before thawing.
- The frozen pipe is inside a finished wall or ceiling: Thawing it safely often means opening the wall or using specialized equipment.
- You want frost-free spigots or new shutoff valves: This means cutting into supply lines and setting the new valve at the right pitch, which is work for a licensed plumber.
- Red flags that need immediate attention:
- Water dripping, spraying, or pooling as a pipe thaws
- The sound of running water when every fixture is off
- No water anywhere in the house, which can mean a frozen main line or a failed pressure-reducing valve
Our plumbing service and repair team handles all of these.
Common Winter Plumbing Mistakes to Avoid
1. Leaving Hoses on Frost-Free Spigots
What people do wrong: Assume a frost-free spigot protects itself, hose or no hose.
Why it’s a problem: Frost-free spigots drain by gravity when shut off. An attached hose blocks that drain, so water stays in the valve body inside your wall, freezes, and cracks it.
The right approach: Disconnect every hose, splitter, and timer before the first hard freeze, whatever kind of spigot you have.
2. Thawing Pipes With a Torch
What people do wrong: Use a propane or butane torch to thaw frozen copper fast.
Why it’s a problem: Open flame can ignite framing, insulation, and paper vapor barriers inside the wall. It can also heat trapped water fast enough to burst the pipe.
The right approach: Use indirect heat like a hairdryer or hot towels, and keep the faucet open while you work.
3. Turning the Heat Too Low
What people do wrong: Drop the thermostat below 55°F overnight or while traveling to save on heating.
Why it’s a problem: Living spaces may stay warm enough, but wall cavities and basement corners can fall below freezing.
The right approach: The American Red Cross recommends keeping the heat no lower than 55°F when you’re away during cold weather. In older homes with drafty foundations, a few degrees higher adds a margin of safety.
Conclusion
Preventing frozen pipes comes down to a short list: drain and shut off outdoor spigots, seal drafts and insulate pipes in cold spaces, and give trapped pressure an exit by dripping faucets on the coldest nights.
If you have pipes running through unheated spaces, want frost-free spigots installed, or aren’t sure your shutoff valves still work, we’re happy to check before the deep cold arrives. We’d rather show up with a checklist in November than a wet-vac in January. Call Fox Plumbing at 717-721-6054.
Serving Lititz, Hershey, Lancaster, Ephrata, Manheim, and the surrounding Central Pennsylvania area.
Frequently Asked Questions
How cold does it have to be for pipes to freeze?
Pipes in unheated areas are at risk once outdoor temperatures drop to about 20°F for several hours. Pipes in drafty crawlspaces, garages, or exterior walls can freeze closer to 28°F, especially on windy nights when cold air reaches them directly.
Should I let my faucets drip during freezing weather?
Yes. On nights below about 20°F, let faucets on exterior walls drip at a pencil-thin stream. The drip slows freezing and, more importantly, relieves pressure, so the pipe is far less likely to burst if ice does form.
What is the difference between a standard spigot and a frost-free spigot?
A standard spigot shuts off at the outside handle, so water sits in the part exposed to the cold. A frost-free spigot has a long stem that places the shutoff valve inside the heated wall, usually 6 to 12 inches in, with the length matched to the wall’s thickness.
How do I know if my outdoor spigot is frozen?
If the spigot gives no water or only a weak dribble while your indoor pressure is normal, the line is likely frozen. Close its interior shutoff if it has one, and watch inside for leaks as it thaws, since a leak can signal a cracked valve.
Can PEX pipe freeze and burst?
Yes, though it’s more forgiving than copper. PEX can stretch slightly as water freezes, but long or repeated freezes can still split the tubing or pull fittings apart, causing a leak once it thaws.
Will foam pipe insulation keep pipes from freezing?
Not on its own. Foam insulation slows heat loss but doesn’t add heat, so pipes in an unheated crawlspace can still freeze during a long cold snap. Pair it with air sealing, or use a thermostat-controlled heat cable on the most exposed lines.
Related Resources
- Residential Plumbing Service & Repairs
- Water Treatment & In-Home Water Testing
- Fox Plumbing Service and Service Areas
Sources
- American Red Cross — Frozen pipes prevention guidance; cited for the 55°F minimum thermostat setting.
- Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) — Freezing and bursting pipes guidance; cited for downstream pressure as the cause of pipe failure.
